Ep. 2269 Barbara Fitzgerald interviews Ellie Mullins | Masterclass US Wine Market
Episode 2269

Ep. 2269 Barbara Fitzgerald interviews Ellie Mullins | Masterclass US Wine Market

Ep. 2269 Barbara Fitzgerald interviews Ellie Mullins | Masterclass US Wine Market

March 3, 2025
67,33958333

Episode Summary

Content Analysis Key Themes and Main Ideas 1. The journey and insights of Ellie Mullens, a Michigan independent wine retailer. 2. Criteria for selecting wines for an independent bottle shop in the US Midwest. 3. The crucial role and value of retailer-importer relationships in connecting wineries to the market. 4. Understanding the unique characteristics of the Michigan wine market (geography, demographics, local production). 5. Consumer preferences and purchasing habits for Italian wines in Southwest Michigan. 6. Strategies and advice for Italian wineries looking to enter or succeed in the US market, particularly Michigan. Summary In this episode of Masterclass US Wine Market, host Barbara Fitzgerald interviews Ellie Mullens, owner of P&E Bottle Shop in Three Oaks, Michigan. Ellie, with over two decades in the wine industry and a family background deeply rooted in wine, shares her expertise on the Michigan retail landscape. She discusses the state's geography, diverse consumer demographics (from local residents to Chicago vacationers), and the evolving perception of Michigan-produced wines. Ellie elaborates on her wine selection process, emphasizing the importance of understanding customer needs, building trust, and curating a wide range of wines, especially Italian ones, from ""wallet-friendly"" options to high-end collectibles. A significant portion of the discussion focuses on the indispensable relationships she cultivates with importers, viewing them as vital bridges to wineries. She also highlights her shop's role as a community hub, deeply attuned to customer preferences. The episode concludes with practical advice for Italian wineries: find a strong importer, build personal connections, and visit the market. Takeaways * Independent wine retailers like Ellie Mullens prioritize trust and community understanding when curating their wine selections. * The Michigan wine market is diverse, encompassing both local wine interest and a strong demand for international wines, including Italian. * Strong, personal relationships between retailers and importers are critical for a successful supply chain and for effectively bringing winery stories and products to consumers. * Consumers often rely on retailer recommendations and trust, especially when exploring new or less familiar wine regions and varieties. * Italian wineries should focus on establishing robust importer relationships and consider direct market engagement (visits, tasting events) to build brand loyalty in the US. * The ""story"" of a wine and winery significantly influences consumer interest and purchase decisions in the retail environment. Notable Quotes * ""Wine, I'd like to say runs in my DNA..."

About This Episode

A wine entrepreneur with over two decades of experience in the industry introduces herself to a group of guests on a wine show and explains her background in wine and her interest in learning about Michigan, specifically the Michigan retail markets. She discusses the importance of independent businesses and the demand for more wine wines in Michigan, as well as the role of Michigan wine in consumer demographics and the success of their own wine country. They also discuss their Italian wines and their love for Italian wines from every region, as well as their professional relationships with importers and distributors. They emphasize the importance of finding the perfect wine in a younger age and invite listeners to stay up-to-date with industry trends.

Transcript

Today, I am really excited to welcome Ellie Mullens to the show. Our three key takeaways for this episode are, first, what a Michigan retailer thinks about when selecting wines for their store. What's the criteria of the wine itself? Of stories they're wanting to share. Next, what is the value of retailer relationships with importers and how this connects, retailers directly to the wineries? And third, what it means to be an independent wine shop in a tight knit community in the Midwest of the United States? So let's dive in. Welcome to Masterclass US wine market with me Barbara Fitzgerald. In this show, we'll break down the complexities of selling wine in the US by discussing the relevant issues of today with experts from around the globe. Each episode serves up three key insights to help elevate your wineries presence in the US market. So grab a pen and paper, and let's pave the way for your success in the US. Hello. Welcome to Masterclass US wine market. Today, I am really excited to welcome Ellie Mullens to the show. Ellie is a wine entrepreneur with over two decades of experience in the industry. She began her journey in California's Santa Barbara AVA where she worked as a mixologist and a wine steward. She's gone on to establish two really highly regarded businesses in Michigan, the first being a specialty food store called local, which featured a small yet really well curated wine selection. And for the past six and a half years, Ellie has owned her and operated her own P and E bottle shop, a boutique wine store in the charming village of three Oaks, Michigan. It's just a short distance from Chicago. So alongside the bottle shop, Ellie and her husband, Pat, also own a pizzeria called Petelli's where they share their love for delicious food with their community. And Ellie's businesses have always been really highly regarded by locals, tourists, and journalists alive thanks to her innate ability to understand her customers and their preferences and provide them with exceptional wine and culinary experiences. So welcome to the show, LA. It's so great to have you here. Thanks for having me, Barb. Yeah. Absolutely. Not only is Ellie an expert on All Things Michigan. She's also my sister-in-law, so I'm really extra glad that you're here joining us this morning. Thank you. And before we dive in today's discussion, Ellie, can you tell us a little bit more about your background and how you came to work in the wine business? Sure. Of course. Wine, I'd like to say runs in my DNA, which is probably why we're family. My brother is a winemaker in Sonoma County, my dad and stepmom grow grapes in Sonoma County since, like, the late nineties. My sister has also been in the the sales side of wine. It's just part of our life and our family. It's what we do. We eat and we drink wine. And we talk about eating and drinking more wine. And my education has been really hands on. It's, like, I was able to work in some really wonderful restaurants and work with really great wine distributors, and I've done a lot of travel. And it's led me to make great relationships with from winemakers to importers to distributors. And there's just always so much more to learn about wine, and I think that's what intrigues me about it. It's like I always have more to discover. And I can never get bored. Yeah. Absolutely. There's always a new page to turn. So I think it's really great to have episodes on the show where we really deep dive into specific markets within the US. So or listeners, you can go back through some of mine and Juliana's episodes to learn about Florida, Connecticut, Colorado, Pennsylvania, to name a few. But in this episode, we're really excited to learn from Ellie all about the Michigan, retail markets. So our three key takeaways for this episode are first, what a Michigan retailer is thinks about when selecting wines for their store. What's the criteria of the wine itself? The stories they're wanting to share? Next, what is the value of retailer relationships with importers and how this connects, retailers directly to the wineries? And third, what it means to be an independent wine shop in a tight knit community in the Midwest of the United States? So let's dive in. So first, let's start with a bit of the geography about the state for those who might not know. So, Ellie, can you explain where Michigan is situated? What is it border? And what are the main metropolitan areas? So Michigan is in the Midwest. We actually are bordered by four great lakes, like Michigan, like Erie, like Huron, Lake Superior, and we sit right above Indiana and Ohio. And just over the border from our largest Metropolitan City, Detroit, Canada. So anyone you meet from Michigan will immediately show you their hand as a a mitten. We're actually divided into part. So there's the upper peninsula that's very rural and a little harder to get to. And then the lower part of the mission of the mitten that is pretty much the the base of the state where all the big cities are. We're in the southwest corner closest about an hour and a half outside of Chicago, but Detroit is probably our biggest city over on this side. It's very vast and obviously had a was bit grown very much during automobile industry. Since then. It's kind of had a new growth over these last ten years. I feel like there's a lot of independent businesses. It's become this hub for the arts and culinary program. So we're seeing a lot of wonderful restaurants, and a lot of great wines, a lot of great art. We also have, like, a lot of college towns. So we've got Ann Arbor and Lansing, and Kalamazoo. Those are definitely younger demographics with a little bit of academics in there. We also have some kind of midsize Midwest cities, Grand Rapids. Those were built with, like, manufacturing and shipping. So there's, like, maybe a little less diversity in those cities, but they're you're seeing a lot of young entrepreneurs and families, like, starting their business because they can have the opportunity to to buy a home and start a business with a little less risk. And there there is a demand for a little bit more in those areas. Absolutely. I think that's what really strikes me when I've visited you in Michigan is how many entrepreneurs are there. And that's a really good call out that it's a great place for somebody to start a business because it's really hard to do that in New York or California. Where it's very expensive. Yes. Exactly. So can you talk a little bit then about the consumer demographics in these main metropolitan areas? And also, you know, you you already spoke a little bit about Detroit specifically, but maybe even more about your area being so closely situated to Chicago and what role that plays. Yes. So we're about an hour and a half drive from Chicago. I like to compare it to in San Francisco driving to the wine country or people in New York driving cats in Valley, where this little getaway, but we do have full time residents. It's definitely, like, not the majority of our population. Our village, I think, has fourteen hundred people year round, but we have so many second homeowners and vacationers. And but people who come here, like, this is part of their regular weekend getaways. So we do also not only have influence from Chicago. We have influence from Detroit, Ann Arbor. We're not far from Notre Dame in South Bend. We have people who come down from Grand Rapids and Kalamazoo. We're a beach community. We have a beautiful, white sandy beaches along the lakes. So during the summer, I would say there's a big population of people coming for, like, family reunions and parties. We're starting to see a lot more of those Bachelorette and ton of weddings. You know, everybody wants kind of that country wedding. So it's a big destination town. Which makes it a really exciting place for wine. These are all events that people want wine for. Right? Oh, yes. Nathan for sure. Yeah. So what role does the fact that Michigan actually has its own wine production areas play in kind of the wine appetite of your local consumers? Well, this is actually a pretty exciting topic because I feel like in the last ten years, we've started getting a little more notable wines coming out of Michigan. We do have a beautiful wine country near us. And when I first moved here, I would say that the reputation for Michigan wine wasn't as great of quality. We had a lot of sweet wines, and and things were just kinda being done more as a hobby than, like, taken seriously. So I do have people who approach it cautiously when they come into the store. But over the last ten years since we've had people kind of make waves with making really thoughtful wines in our area, I now have people who come, like, looking, seeking for Michigan wine. It's been exciting. It's still a small percentage of what we do, but we're proud of it. And I'm excited to showcase it. So, I mean, I always have a a handful of wines in my shop, and I can always recommend some good wineries for people to go to. I don't know that would ever, like, be the bulk of what we we would do, but we're proud that we do have some really talented winemakers, and we have some great things to show in our state. Definitely. Do you think that it translates though to your consumers being more interested in wines in general? Or is it just kind of the Michigan focus that they No. I would say it is people interested in wines in general. I mean, some, I will admit, are cautious. They're like, you know, like, I have this beautiful, you know, from Michigan, and they're like, oh, from Michigan. And I I love to say, like, you trust me because you come into the store and you trust me, and I have not steered you wrong. And I'll even be like, you know, if their guests is nervous about it, I'm like, blind them on it. And then and then have them taste it and then after be like, yeah. That was made here in Michigan. So it's pretty cool. But I think it is wine lovers who are interested, but they are definitely a little cautious because it's still new. Yeah. But I think that you mentioned a really important point about you as a as a retail shop owner that your consumers trust you and that you've worked really hard to build that relationship with them. So when trying anything new, whether it's a wine from Michigan or a wine from Italy you know, you already have their ear. Yes. I hope so. And I I mean, I do. It's pretty cool. It's a fun relationship we have. We do. Yes. Definitely. Well, let's look a little bit more specifically now at at your area of Southwest Michigan. And what kind of Italian wines are your consumers looking for, especially in terms of price and taste profile? It's a big range. I would say we do because of our community being, like, We have parties. We have, like, the, you know, we have people coming up and having a big party at a lake house or a wedding. We also have a lot of retirees in the area who like to have parties every weekend. So But both probably the most volume that we sell in the shop are what I like to call our wallet friendly wines, which are sixteen and under. So there, we have some really recognizable labels. Like, we have some peontes, some marbarade asti, some pinot grigio, But we also have some wines to introduce them to, which, like, Alianico and Elangina and Feano, Pecarino. We try to, you know, say, well, if you'd like this, you'd like this. And I will say our wallet friendly wines are not mass produced wines either. They're still, like, really thoughtfully made wines, but it's just like a good way to get people into the door with that. The next portion of our shop, I would say, we do sell, like, a lot of twenty five to fifty dollar bottle of wines. Those will have a lot of, again, recognizable wines, like, more, you know, higher end mid range and chiantis, Lavera Dalvas, some nice, like, nebbiolos from the longue, some multipuchiano, some sicilians. Cecilians really been catching on, and some Vermentino. But I will say because of our shop and our our clientele is so diverse that I have come people who come in and they wanna spend a hundred and thirty dollars on the six bottles of Palabaeus, Argentina, I got for an old, a twenty seventeen barolo sells really well, but definitely that's not volume wise. I don't sell as many of those, but I definitely need them in my shop. I try to have you know, those everyday party wines, those just nice dinner wines, and then, like, kind of those I have a few of those once in a lifetime bottles, and I'm I'm lucky enough to get them in the shop. Yeah. That's wonderful. So you do have consumers across the board who want those everyday drinkers, but also who are looking for those special products and and maybe even those, I'll say, more highly regarded. A Italian wines too. Yeah. Definitely. So how important is the winery story to your consumers? Would you say most more of them want to know the romantic details of the winery? I mean, it's one of my favorite parts. And so I think it is. I think they love it because I share those stories with them all the time, and I think that draws them to the wines. I don't know that they remember the stories completely, but I would say too when my consumers have traveled in Italy, they come in and they're sharing those stories with me as well. I can't tell you how many times people are coming back from a trip and showing me photos on their phone and asking me about stuff. So I would say we love those stories. I think that's what attaches us to the wines themselves. And have you ever kind of from your consumers, like, learned about a wine that you've then brought into your shop from a visit of theirs? Oh, wow. I'm sure, but let me think about it. I mean, definitely from you, but that's true. My brother, for sure, not right now off the top of my head in Italy, I would say. But, I mean, they are there's so many wineries, which is tough, you know, because people will come in and they'll be like, do you know this winery? And most of the time, I'm like, maybe? No. But yeah. But they haven't yet. So I'll have to keep an eye out for them. Yes. People have visited wineries that I know and love. So that's been kind of cool. Yeah. Definitely. And then, like, bring me little cards or something from there. Little mementos. Yes. Well, let's talk a little bit more now about your kinda more professional relationships. So how do you build your relationships with their importers? And how are they really acting as a bridge to the wineries in your portfolio? They're huge. Those relationships have been the most important relationships for my business. It's been interesting because now I have been since before this job. I had the specialty grocery. I have been selling wine in Michigan for about fourteen years. So it took me a little while to build these relationships. But I've met them from, I mean, just like your classic tasting events or the ride alongs with distributors, and also just like kind of going down those holes of emails, like, who's this person Who's this person? How can I get this wine? How can I get this wine? Sometimes I'll reach out to a winery directly when I'm looking for a wine, and they're like, this is who I work with in this state. And so over time, I've met importers, and we connected. We've come they've come into the shop. We've done tastings. We ended up we've done a lot of dinners together, wine dinners together. But, really, we've kind of become friends And that's been just special. I think when you when everybody's so passionate about wine, it's just, like, they're your friend in the wine world, and they wanna share things with you. You wanna hear about their travels. I mean, it's so fun when my importers or distributors are traveling throughout Italy and visiting wineries, and they're, like, texting me stuff. I just think it's the coolest thing. I'm like, oh my gosh, they're there right now, and they're sending me this major picture. It just makes you me feel connected. Absolutely. And what a beautiful thing for even a an Italian winery, a producer to know, like, the conversation that is being had about their wines and the people getting excited about it along the way? I hear often from Italian wineries that I work with, you know, that they send their wine to the US, and then they have no idea what happens with it and what people are saying about it. And so you they should know that people are saying wonderful things and getting really excited about about what they're doing. Yeah. And I think they're importers. I mean, I'm I just am so fortunate to work with them because they're the ones that really tie it all together for me. Absolutely. Well, would you mind mentioning a few of the names of the importers you work with in case there's an Italian winery looking for one out there. Oh, for sure. Locai imports, l o c I a l o c I is one of my absolute favorite. They're newer and just really finding the most thoughtfully produced wines. I really love some bigger name ones that you I'm sure no. Banville wine merchants has been amazing. I've had a lot of fun doing tasting events and dinners with them as well. The sorting table, I think, is just really wonderful. It's one that kind of bridges across outside of Italy as well and even domestically, but their wines are wonderful. I also love some of the bigger names like Rosenthal, you know, is such a great representation of wines from a certain area. I also try to teach my consumers, my customers in the shop, when I'm not there, which is rare, or if they're somewhere else and they don't they always ask me, like, how do I know how to buy wine? I tell them to get to know their the importers they love and look for those on the label because you can trust them. That's a really great piece of advice for consumers. I do the same if I'm in a restaurant and I'm like, oh, this is Oliver McCrum. I'm gonna like it. Yeah. Or something like that. Totally. So let's talk a little bit more about the specifics of your shop how many wines do you have in total? And how many of those are Italian wines? At this point, we have over nine hundred wines in inventory. And I would say about thirty percent is Italian, and was speaking that I really have wines from all over the world. You know, that's a really good majority of the shop. I would say thirty percent because I have wines from everywhere, from the country of Georgia, and Serbia, Slovenia, and Croatia. So That's very cool. It's hard for me not to keep buying Italian wine. No one here, will fault you for that. And what would you say some, like, favorite producers, specific producers in your shop are? For the Italian wines. Yeah. I would say I would like some every night ones that I love are, like, aperinara out of Campania, Italy. I just think they make really, like, pure approachable wines. I love bison wines. From LaGoria. I love Elena Valsch. Oh my god. The wines are just gorgeous. I love anything by Elizabeth Deforadore. I think just some really easy approachable wines and price points, the g d Vadro wines are are really wonderful. And some newer ones that I've really been loving, la Columbara from Hedmont. It's Yeah. Is is beautiful. Tamaraso is gorgeous. No. I but I love this because I think our listeners are really getting a sense You have a wide range of really interesting and unique wines for your consumers, and they're excited about that. Yeah. I would say often people come into my store who are coming in for the first time, and they're like, I don't know any of these wines. And what's really fun to introduce them, or they see, you know, just specific ones that they're like, oh, I haven't seen this anywhere. I've seen this, you know, I have this once at a restaurant in New York or somewhere. And so I feel very fortunate to get to have it here in the shop. That's fantastic. And as someone who's been to your shop, I can attest to the fact that you really are a hub for your community. I mean, it's it's kind of come up a few times in the episode, how much people value you in their lives and how much they trust you. And even with the tourists, you're able to really kind of understand them and make great recommendations for them. So how do you communicate the features and benefits of a wine to really fit the needs and values of your customers? And how are you even understanding what those needs and values are? Well, I think first off, I'm like, well, what's this for? What are you doing? Are you eating? Are you? I'm always like, what's the weather like? I love your lips updated. I'm very seasonal with drinking. And then I always try to find their price point in the crowd that they're serving to. I think it's nice. When people are serving a crowd, they don't I try not to put them in a quarter by picking something like specific that people know. I actually try to find something that people don't know so that in case anybody has strong feelings about something, they can be like, oh, no. This is new thing that you're gonna like. Yeah. It really just depends on that. So if it's like a beach day or a party, I'm looking at some light bright reds and rosays and bubbles always chillable reds, but it's just about listening to them and knowing my inventory and being able to suggest and share with them some wines that would fit their needs for that occasion. Yeah. I love that because I've also seen some of your customers come back and say, you know, that you are part of their special celebrations because you make such fantastic recommendations for them and they're having their get together. Yeah. It's funny in a small town. I often know, like, what's being served at a party so that somebody's coming to go to the party and bring the host a gift. I'll be like, well, they already bought this. So you wanna get this. Yeah. For those that are also thinking of taking a trip to Southwest Michigan, now you know how well curated your your woman experiences can be while there. Okay. So as we kinda start to wind down a little bit, we'd like to have our rapid fire quiz where we ask our guests three questions to help our listeners better understand the US market and specifically this episode, the Michigan market. So just answer in a couple sentences if you can. What is your number one tip for an Italian winery to kinda master the Michigan wine market. Oh, wow. I would say to find a wonderful importer, build a great relationship with them, come visit, come visit us, come to our shops, get to know our clientele, If you have a wonderful importer, you'll have a wonderful distributor that will set you up with, like, some great tasting events and some dinners. And the more that we all have that, like, hands on, it's kind of like that touch It's a touch to have a high touch job. If we feel like we, like, get to know you, then you're just part of our shock forever, and we're always excited about the wines that were brought into our country and to our state and to our shop. That's fantastic. And again, I just wanna remind everyone what you called out in the beginning, you know, such an interesting market with a lot of academics, a lot of kind of high income individuals with maybe second homes. So definitely a wine curious appetite. Mhmm. Yeah. So number two, what is something you would have told your younger professional self about selling wine in the US? I would say travel more when you're younger, which I mean, I talk to, but I would I would even do more. And I would love to have learned more languages at a younger age. So I wish I could have done that. I just speak French. I wish I could speak with Italian and Spanish too. So There's always there's always time. What is your favorite Italian wine you've discovered in your market? And that is like picking what kid is favorite. So it changes by my mood and my day and everything. But I would say most recently I'll have to go back to La columbres to Marasso because I got to taste some older vintages of it as well, and just like it's such a purity driven wine with incredible aging potential. And I I also love to call out, like, the beautiful white wines from Italy and the indigenous grapes because they are truly just some of my favorites. And We aren't here yet. Yeah. I'm with you. I we we actually at our business forum, wine to wine, in verona in November did a whole tasting seminar on Italian Agible white wines because there are so many wonderful, and yes, Timaraso definitely up there. Okay. Well, Ellie, that was all our questions. So thank you so much for joining us. Today on Master Class USOI Market. How can our listeners connect with you? We have our website at w w w dot PEbottleshop dot com. My husband is Pat, and I'm Ellie, so it's PE, and then we're on Instagram at PE bottle shop, and we're also on Facebook. Wonderful. So good for importers or Italian wineries to reach out to you, but also consumers. This is like a you said a vacation destination and and you're a real draw to to the beach life. Thank you. Well, thanks again, Ellie. We really appreciate your time, and, I know I'll be seeing you very soon. Looking forward to it. Cheers. Take care. And that's a wrap for this episode of Masterclass US wine market. Thank you so much for joining us. If you enjoyed this episode and want to stay up to date with the latest industry trends, remember to like, follow and share our podcast. And if you find value in our conversations, please leave us a review to help others discover the show and grow our community. Stay tuned for new episodes every Monday. Until then,