
Ep. 2519 Wine and Crime at Venice Noir with David Hewson and Philip Gwynne Jones | Book Club with Richard Hough
Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode Summary
**Content Analysis** **Key Themes** 1. **Journalism as Foundation for Crime Writing** - The contrast between journalistic truth-telling and fictional storytelling, with both authors emphasizing the importance of editing and rewriting while maintaining freedom to create compelling narratives. 2. **Italy as Literary Character** - Venice and Italy function as more than settings; they provide authentic cultural texture through food, wine, seasonality, and history that ground crime narratives in place and community. 3. **Food and Wine as Narrative Bridges** - Culinary elements serve dual purposes: they create atmospheric richness and social authenticity while providing shorthand for character development and intimate conversations within the stories. 4. **Venice Noir as Community-Building Festival** - The festival represents a deliberate rejection of mass-market events in favor of boutique, accessible gatherings that foster genuine connections between authors and readers through shared experiences. 5. **Career Transitions and Authenticity** - Both writers embraced significant life changes (journalism to fiction, career changes to Italy) that informed their ability to write from outsider perspectives with credibility and depth. **Summary** David Hewson and Philip Gwynne Jones discuss their parallel yet distinct journeys into crime fiction, both deeply rooted in Italy. Hewson transitioned from journalism through a transformative holiday in Spain, while Jones relocated to Venice through economic circumstance and discovered writing through blogging. The conversation explores how their work integrates Italian food, wine, and setting as essential narrative elements rather than superficial details. They reveal the Venice Noir Festival's origins in casual bookshop discussions and its evolution into a free, three-day event featuring acclaimed authors like Ian Rankin. Both writers emphasize their commitment to authentic representation of Italian life while maintaining creative license, and discuss how their outsider status—Hewson as frequent visitor, Jones as resident British consul character creator—enables fresh perspectives on Italian culture and noir traditions. **Key Takeaways** - Journalism teaches essential editing discipline but risks over-commitment to factuality; effective fiction requires strategic dishonesty while maintaining believable authenticity. - Regional Italian food and wine traditions offer powerful narrative tools that ground stories in specific place and season, creating cultural verisimilitude that readers instinctively recognize. - Venice and Italian settings transcend tourism clichés when writers engage deeply with history, architecture, and everyday life rather than postcard aesthetics. - The Venice Noir Festival deliberately prioritizes intimate, free access and substantive panel discussions (e.g., putting Casanova on trial) over conventional book festival formulas. - Personal life circumstances—career crises, relocations, holidays—can trigger creative breakthroughs and provide authentic perspectives that strengthen literary narratives. - Outsider status (whether as visitor or resident foreigner) paradoxically enables more credible storytelling about place than native-insider perspectives might provide. **Notable Quotes** - "Everything that makes journalism good makes fiction bad because as a journalist, you're trying to tell the absolute truth. And what you're trying to do as a novelist is tell a whopping great lie that appears to be the truth." - "When they want to have a discussion outside the office, they don't go to a café, they would go and have a pizza. That's how it was, in Rome...the fact that that had that social function, I thought was very interesting." - "We want to be compact. We want to be kind of a boutique festival where people get to meet and mingle and leaders and authors get to chat, and there's a social side to it." **Follow-up Questions** 1. How do crime writers balance depicting authentic regional Italian criminal practices versus perpetuating stereotypes, particularly regarding Sicily and organized crime narratives? 2. What strategies do Hewson and Jones employ to update their work as restaurants, bars, and neighborhoods in Venice transform due to tourism and economic pressures? 3. Beyond literary festivals, what roles do platforms like Blue Sky and independent blogs play in maintaining direct author-reader relationships compared to traditional publishing infrastructure?
About This Episode
The speakers discuss various topics including a small, social festival with a community building over the years, a book about a nuclear submarine, and a video about a nuclear submarine. They also recommend books on firearms and language learning, and mention a book club and book on firearms. Speaker 1 and Speaker 2 discuss their experiences with language learning and suggest improving pronunciation. They end by thanking Speaker 1 for their time and mentioning a book club next week.
Transcript
We're not trying to be, an event that has thousands and thousands of visitors. We want to be compact. We want to be a kind of a boutique festival where people get to meet and mingle and leaders and authors get to chat, and there's a social side to it. And there's a community building over the years. So it's the start. It's the very first one. There'll be a few rough edges, but, you know, the basics are there. We've got the authors. We've got the venues, and I think we've got some great subjects to talk about. So I hope anybody who's listening, if you wanna come along, can't know. You're coming, Richard. So it'd be lovely to see you there. Yeah. There will be food and drink. Don't forget that. There will be food and drink as well. Yes. Yeah. There will be food and drink. Hello, and welcome to book club with the Italian wine podcast. I'm your host, Richard Hoff, and I'm delighted that you're joining us as we get between the vines with some of the best wine writing out there. So sit back, pour yourself a glass, and enjoy the show with the Italian Wine Podcast. This month, our guests are two renowned crime writers who have embraced Italy as the backdrop for their murder mystery thriller, David Hewson and Philip Gwyn Jones. Hi, chaps. Welcome to the Italian Wine Podcast. Thank you so much. It's a pleasure to be here. Yep. Me too. Great. So this is something of a first for the show, because you're not wine writers, but you do have very deep links with Italy, not least its food and wine, which I know you both enjoy. Especially, Negroni's, I think in your case Oh, we'll get around to those, I'm sure. Yes. Okay. So I'm very much, looking forward to exploring some of that with you in our conversation. First though, I just want to understand a little bit more about your your backgrounds and your origins as crime writers. And starting with you, David, your journalistic career began as a 17 year old I did. At the Scarborough Evening News. Yeah. You then went on to work with the Times and the Independent. So can you tell us just a bit about your your life as a journalist, your work as a journalist? What kind of memorable stories did you cover? And how did that background prepare you for being a crime writer? Well, you know, I I went into journalism because I wanted to write, and I couldn't think of anything else to do. Mhmm. I always wanted to write books, but you didn't have an experience as a young person. So, you know, I was literally covering flower shows and and minor car crashes and court cases, when I was 17, and then somehow clawed my way onto the times and then the independent on the Sunday Times. And, you know, I I covered business. I covered foreign reporting. I was the asked correspondent for a while. And then on The Sunday Times, I was a technology columnist, for quite a while. So I did I did lots of different sorts of stuff. In terms of how journalism prepares you for being a writer, in one way, it's a great preparation because you learn that your words need to be edited. You know, you're not precious about what you've written. And, you know, I work with some great journalists over the years and some great editors who taught me stuff that I was able to pass on to other people. And that's really important when you're writing whether you're writing a book or a press release or what everything. You know, you're gonna take feedback. You've got to accept that people can improve your work. And I found that a lot of people who try to become authors later on are just so amazed that they've actually written something that they don't want to change a single word, which is a a real mistake. So that side of being a journalist is very good in that you you understand that editing and rewriting, they're both incredibly important. The bad side of it is that, you know, everything that makes journalism good makes fiction bad because as a journalist, you're trying to tell the absolute truth. And what you're trying to do as a as a novelist is tell a whopping great lie that appears to be the truth. So everything that makes fiction work would get you fired as a journalist. So, you know, I think you can get hooked up. I mean, some journalists who become writers become obsessed with fact and have to get everything absolutely right. And my approach is if something is meant to be factual in a book, and often I will use factual stuff, then I will endeavor to make it right, but I will still feel the freedom to lie big time whenever I feel like it. So it it swings and roundabouts, really. Okay. And when did you make the transition in from journalism to Well, I was I I I knew that I had to find the time to write because there was no way I was gonna write a book if I was commuting into London into an office. So I eventually managed to wangle my way on to be a columnist, a weekly columnist on the Sunday Times, which meant I could work from home. So I was writing the book in the morning and then working as for the Sunday Times in the afternoon and the evenings. And then, eventually, I was able to the the books took up enough, but I can just say terrified my wife. But I said, that's it. I'm giving up journalism for good, and that was over twenty years ago. And with hindsight, I think I should probably have given it up earlier, but I was you know, there were kids and bills to pay, so I didn't. But, but it was always something I I I wanted to do. And it was in, you know, I was in my early forties when it happened. I'd actually given up. I'd stopped thinking about being a writer, and then we had a holiday in Southern Spain, at Easter. And the weather was absolutely terrible, awful. And there was a book on the bookshelf, an Ed McBain, great Ed McBain crime story, 87 Precinct. And I read that, and I just thought I'd forgotten. That's this is what I want to do. And that prompted me into, trying to write a book. And and that's how it all started. Interesting. And how did your career then take shape in those early days of finding an editor, having a story? Well, it very nearly didn't. It very nearly didn't. I wrote, you know, my first book, which I call Samantha Center. I wrote it, and I followed all the things it tells you to do in the the writer's yearbook. You know, like, you write a letter to all the agents explaining who you are and what the book's like. They all came back and said we're not interested. We don't even want to read it. Who wants to read a book set in Spain? And I was spending a lot of time in America at the time, so I thought I'd get myself an agent in New York. I was about to go to New York, and I sent it I faxed because these these are the days of fax. There was no email. I actually faxed these things around to loads of agents. Most of everyone ignored it apart from one agent came back and said, you can't do this. You're English. You need an English agent. My mate in England might be interested. Now her mate in England was a wonderful woman called Vivienne Shuster, who was like the queen of literary agents at the time. She represented everybody. And, she worked for Curtis Brown. Curtis Brown had already said they didn't wanna read the book. But Viv phoned me, and she said, Edith, she'll talk about it. You know? Of course, I didn't say, actually, you've already said you don't want to read the book. But she did the thing saying, I'd like to read the first 10 pages, Then she said, I'd like to read the next 50 pages. Then she wanted to read it all, and then she took it on. And within a space of three months, I had a three book contract with Robert Collins. And six months later, I've got a film deal. And they made the they made a film of it. It's a truly terrible film, but they made a film of it. So, you know, that's that's publishing. You know? I think it's probably even more bizarre than that now. But, but back in those days, you know, it was just your luck and a prayer. And you, Philip, your background is completely different. It's very different to David. Yes. You were
Episode Details
Related Episodes

Ep. 2639 Sustainable Wine Stories: Climate, Bottling & Reasons for Optimism with Andrew Neather | Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode 2639

Ep. 2581 Why Humans Love to Drink with Professor Edward Slingerland | Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode 2581

Ep. 2560 Sophie Thorpe’s Wine Books of 2025 | Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode 2560

Ep. 2532 The Wines of Beaujolais with Natasha Hughes MW | Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode 2532

Ep. 2411 Paul Balke | Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode 2411

Ep 2380 Jessica Dupuy | Book Club with Richard Hough
Episode 2380
