Ep. 875 Vine & Prejudice Chapter 4 | Everybody Needs A Bit Of Scienza
Episode 875

Ep. 875 Vine & Prejudice Chapter 4 | Everybody Needs A Bit Of Scienza

Everybody Needs A Bit Of Scienza

April 21, 2022
54,92083333
Vine & Prejudice
wine
evolution
plants
podcasts
north america

Episode Summary

Content Analysis Key Themes and Main Ideas 1. The re-evaluation of *Vitis* (grapevine) taxonomy in light of new genetic understanding. 2. Historical evolutionary theories (e.g., Darwin, Wallace) and their application to species classification. 3. The concepts of speciation (allopatric and sympatric) in the context of plant evolution. 4. The significance of hybridization and introgression in the evolutionary history of *Vitis*. 5. The biodiversity of North American *Vitis* species and their potential for developing resistant rootstocks. 6. The influence of climate change on *Vitis* behavior, evolution, and hybridization. Summary This episode introduces a chapter from Professor Yoshi Shinsa's book, translated and narrated by Richard Huff, focusing on the classification and evolution of the *Vitis* genus. It argues for reopening the debate on *Vitis* taxonomy, asserting that new genetic understanding supersedes previous scientific conclusions. The text revisits Alfred Wallace's contributions to the theory of evolution and speciation, contrasting it with Darwin's, and highlights how understanding speciation (the creation of new species) is crucial. It discusses the historical dominance of allopatric speciation (requiring geographical isolation) and the more recent prominence of sympatric speciation (divergence without isolation). The chapter emphasizes that hybridization and introgression play significant roles in *Vitis* evolution, often challenging traditional classifications. It points out that North American *Vitis* species, with their high biodiversity, represent an unexplored potential for developing new resistant rootstocks through hybridization. The text concludes by noting the trend towards reducing the number of formally recognized *Vitis* species, considering many to be natural crossings, and acknowledging new discoveries in China. Takeaways - Modern genetic understanding necessitates a re-evaluation of the classification and taxonomy of the *Vitis* genus. - Traditional taxonomic approaches, focused on creating rigid categories, are being superseded by the modern evolutionary synthesis which emphasizes individual characteristics and population dynamics. - Alfred Wallace's theory of speciation and biogeography offers insights into species dispersal and divergence. - Speciation can occur either allopatrically (with geographical isolation) or sympatrically (without it), with sympatric speciation gaining recent prominence for *Vitis*. - Hybridization and introgression are key processes in the evolution of *Vitis* species, leading to complex genetic flows between seemingly distant species. - North America possesses significant biodiversity within its native *Vitis* species, offering potential for developing new disease-resistant rootstocks. - Climate change, such as glacial cycles, can trigger hybridization between different *Vitis* species. Notable Quotes - ""The answer is obvious and can be found in the new understanding We now have about the genetic structure of the genus *Vitis*."

About This Episode

The Italian wine podcast discusses the history and classification of species, as well as the potential for new research on genetic competition and biology. The discussion also touches on the potential for hybridization between species and the potential impact of climate change on species distribution. The podcast is a resource for viewers to visit the show and receive free content.

Transcript

Welcome to the Italian wine podcast. This episode is brought to you by Vineetili International Wine and Spirits. The fifty fourth edition of Vineetili was held from the tenth to the thirteenth of April. If you missed it, don't worry, go to benitely plus dot com for on demand recordings of all the sessions from the exhibition. Welcome to Professoria Tiyoshinsa's newest book translated and narrated by Richard Huff. This latest publication is part of the mama jumbo shrimp series entitled, mama jumbo shrimp Guide to Vine and Prejudice, fake science and the search for the perfect grape. This is a great way to get a sneak peek at the book before it hits the shelves, so listen in and let the geeky knowledge seep into your ears because we all need a little bit of Shinsa. Chapter four, the classification and evolution of species. Does it make sense to reopen the debate surrounding the taxonomy of divine now? Aren't the conclusions of countless scientific studies, above all, those of the last century sufficient. The answer is obvious and can be found in the new understanding We now have about the genetic structure of the genus fetus. Although it may be inconvenient for those scientists working in the field of Viticulture, research ethics requires them to accept the results of their studies, even if they are unexpected. Alfred Wallace, the British naturalist, and contemporary of Darwin, with whom he independently conceived the theory of evolution through natural selection, expanded on the theory of speciation rejecting the hypothesis of a land bridge between continents and introducing the new science of biogeography. The study of how and why species are dispersed across the planets. For Wallace, this theory was based on the belief that differences between related living organisms were the consequence of the independent evolution of a group within the same species. When this happened, as a result, for example, of continental drift or the demands of a different environmental context, the characteristic of the members of the new group would differentiate the new species from their ancestors. The existence of speciation, the creation of two species from one, was at odds with the theory of adaptation, the evolutionary process whereby An organism becomes better able to live in its habitat or habitats. Adaptation helps organisms perform certain tasks better, such as finding food or evading predators. Spreciation, on the other hand, occurs when a single species splits into two or more contemporaneous descendant species, a process less easily explained by natural selection. Unfortunately, Wallace, like Darwin, failed to distinguish the different components of evolutionary history or phylogeny that produce different types of relationships. Genealogy, divergence, polarity, or evolutionary direction. The legacy prevails of a kind of fundamentalist philosophy of science, which in the last two hundred years, has seen the main task of naturalists to be the creation of taxonomic categories, species, genus, families, classes, which has been superseded by the modern evolutionary synthesis. And which identified the starting point of the evolutionary process and the individual characteristics of the various populations. Over time, naturalistic botanical, agronomic, physiochemical and genetic competencies have alternated, integrated, and overlapped, leading to refinements in Amplolography, the identification and classification of grapevines, in parallel with the formation of an increasingly structured and shared language. Despite this, there remained a widespread persistence until the beginning of the nineteenth century of a great skepticism regarding the usefulness, indeed, of the very possibility of a serious morphological taxonomic study of vines. Until the nineteen seventies, the concept of allopatric speciation prevailed. According to this theory, a degree of geographical isolation such as that between the American and Asian continents were necessary for two populations to develop reproductive divergence. More recently, the concept of sympatric speciation has gained prominence in which the divergence between two inter fertile populations can also occur in the absence of geographical isolation. The American species of Janice Rita represent an ideal model for the study of hybridization and introgression because they are known to be potentially interfertile. In addition to the existence of so called parent species, recent research has provided evidence of numerous gene flows between apparently genetically distant species. Even hypothesizing that the current geographic distributions of the species are not necessarily predictive of the interactions that have occurred in the past. And that the behavior of the plant in the face of climate change, for example, glacial cycles may be idiosyncratic and have triggered the hybridization between different species. In North America, there are thought to be an estimated nineteen native vine species. Though some estimates put the figure at closer to twenty five known species, mostly coming from the eastern regions of the Rocky Mountains. This great biodiversity within the American species represents a highly unexplored potential for producing new resistant rootstocks through hybridization. The current trend and classification has seen a reduction in the number of species, often the result of natural crossings, with the addition of new species discovered in China. Thanks for listening to this episode of the Italian wine podcast brought to you by Vineetly International Wine and Spirits exhibition, the biggest drinks trade fair in the world. Remember to subscribe to Italian wine podcast and catch us on SoundCloud spotify, and wherever you get your pods. You can also find us at Italian wine podcast dot com. Hi, guys. I'm Joy Livingston, and I am the producer of the Italian wine podcast. Thank you for listening. We are the only wine podcast that has been doing a daily show since the pandemic began. This is a labor of love and we are committed to bring you free content every day. Of course, this takes time and effort not to mention the cost of equipment, production, and editing. We would be grateful for your donations, suggestions, requests, and ideas. For more information on how to get in touch, go to Italianwine podcast dot com.